Too much choice could undermine pension outcomes - EIOPA

European pension savers risk making no decisions at all when faced with too many complex choices, the European Insurance and Occupational Pensions Authority (EIOPA) has warned, urging policymakers to ensure pension systems deliver good retirement outcomes by default.

Speaking at the PensionsEurope Annual Conference 2026 in Lisbon, EIOPA head of policy and supervisory convergence, Patrick Hoedjes, argued that policymakers needed to reconsider how supplementary pension systems were structured, warning that excessive choice, misconceptions around investment risk and a lack of understanding of collective benefits could undermine retirement outcomes.

Hoedjes stressed that while individual choice was generally viewed positively, offering savers too many options could create barriers to pension participation and effective decision-making.

"Choice, in a way, is something that we appreciate as people," he said.

However, he questioned whether this necessarily translated into better pension outcomes, particularly when individuals were faced with complex decisions about whether and how to save.

Highlighting the importance of automatic enrolment (AE), Hoedjes stated: "People know that it's good for them, but they just don't know what choice to make."

He warned that individuals could consequently end up making no decision at all, rather than actively participating in pension saving.

"Make sure that in your design, you make the simple way, the way that requires no choice at all, a good outcome for citizens," he urged.

Hoedjes also questioned whether policymakers were placing too much responsibility on individuals to make appropriate pension decisions, arguing that greater financial literacy alone would not resolve shortcomings in pension system design.

Instead, he stressed that policymakers had a responsibility to ensure pension options were straightforward and structured around members' interests.

Turning to investment risk, Hoedjes challenged conventional perceptions of risk in pension saving, suggesting that excessive caution could undermine long-term retirement outcomes.

"We as supervisors, we also warn, often warn, be careful," he acknowledged, highlighting the negative connotations frequently associated with higher-risk investments.

However, he argued that this approach did not necessarily reflect the long-term nature of pension saving.

"Risk-taking is a good thing," he stated.

"You need to have more risk, but of course you also want to outrun inflation at the end of the day."

Hoedjes suggested that the industry's focus on investment volatility could sometimes overshadow the more fundamental challenge of longevity risk.

He also highlighted the importance of collective pension arrangements in addressing this challenge, arguing that risk-sharing mechanisms could help protect individuals against the possibility of outliving their retirement savings.

However, Hoedjes acknowledged that savers often misunderstood the collective element of pension provision and could worry about what would happen to their accumulated savings if they died earlier than expected.

"Social element of a pension system simply means you protect yourself against the risk of longevity," he explained.

"It's not because you want to be friendly to your neighbours. It's in your own self-interest."

He suggested that a common concern among individuals considering collective pension arrangements was: "What happens to my money if I die young?"

Hoedjes argued this reflected a wider misunderstanding of the purpose of collective risk-sharing arrangements, which were intended to protect individuals against longevity risk.

"It's in your own interest, and we need to learn to adapt our language when we talk about pensions reform," he stated.

He also emphasised the importance of policymakers taking responsibility for designing effective pension systems, rather than relying on individuals to navigate increasingly complex retirement decisions.

Hoedjes subsequently called for greater transparency over pension fund performance, costs and investment returns, suggesting that clearer information could strengthen accountability and improve competition between providers.

"I think the transparency is an element that we need to get right," he said.

"How much do I pay in? How much costs are deducted?"

He argued that making this information more accessible would enable savers and pension institutions to better understand and compare investment performance, encouraging improvements in efficiency and retirement outcomes.

Meanwhile, Hoedjes highlighted the importance of the European Union's Savings and Investments Union (SIU), arguing that greater integration was essential to strengthening Europe's pension and financial systems.

"It's an opportunity. No, it's a necessity," he noted, warning that continued fragmentation across European markets was undermining the bloc's ability to respond to economic and geopolitical challenges.

"The SIU is not a matter of taking the opportunity to bring additional products to our citizens," he continued, describing it instead as a fundamental reform needed to improve the functioning of the European internal market.

He stressed that the overarching objective of pension reform must remain delivering better outcomes for savers, with pension arrangements designed around individuals' long-term interests rather than simply expanding the range of available financial products.



Share Story:

Recent Stories


Podcast: Stepping up to the challenge
In the latest European Pensions podcast, Natalie Tuck talks to PensionsEurope chair, Jerry Moriarty, about his new role and the European pension policy agenda

Podcast: The benefits of private equity in pension fund portfolios
The outbreak of the Covid-19 pandemic, in which stock markets have seen increased volatility, combined with global low interest rates has led to alternative asset classes rising in popularity. Private equity is one of the top runners in this category, and for good reason.

In this podcast, Munich Private Equity Partners Managing Director, Christopher Bär, chats to European Pensions Editor, Natalie Tuck, about the benefits private equity investments can bring to pension fund portfolios and the best approach to take.

Mitigating risk
BNP Paribas Asset Management’s head of pension solutions, Julien Halfon, discusses equity hedging with Laura Blows

Advertisement